Supreme Court Formally Closes Case Over Lake Willoughby Tower

The approval of a 140-foot telecommunications tower near Lake Willoughby stands after the Vermont Supreme Court on Tuesday officially closed a legal challenge brought by several Westmore residents. The group's effort centered on concerns about the tower's impact on the area’s scenic landscape.

Background: Proposal and Local Opposition

Industrial Tower and Wireless, a Massachusetts-based company, submitted a petition in June 2024 to construct the tower just northwest of Lake Willoughby, a recognized national natural landmark in Vermont’s Northeast Kingdom. The proposal aimed to improve radio and cellular service in the region. However, it was met with opposition from locals who raised concerns over the visual impact on Lake Willoughby and its surrounding forested areas.

Community Response and Key Arguments

Seven Westmore residents formally challenged the project, arguing that the Vermont Public Utility Commission did not adequately consider input from the town’s planning commission, select board, the town plan, or neighbors when it approved the telecommunications tower's construction. Despite these efforts, the Public Utility Commission granted project approval in September 2025.

Legal Challenge Moves Through Courts

After the initial approval, the residents filed a notice of appeal with the Vermont Supreme Court. The court heard the appeal, and on September 4, upheld the Public Utility Commission’s decision. Still determined, the residents filed a motion for reargument on September 16, seeking another review of the case. This motion was denied on September 29, as reported by the Newport Daily Express.

Final Supreme Court Action Leaves Tower Approval Intact

On Tuesday, the Vermont Supreme Court issued a notice certifying the case back to the Public Utility Commission, formally closing the appellate process. With the Supreme Court’s latest action, the approval for the telecommunications tower remains in place, clearing the way for its potential construction near Lake Willoughby.

Looking Ahead

The decision concludes a lengthy process involving community advocacy, regulatory review, and judicial scrutiny. Industrial Tower and Wireless now maintains approval to proceed with the tower, which has been debated over both its benefits for communications infrastructure and its impact on the scenic local environment. Any additional actions regarding the project will now return to the Public Utility Commission.

Source: vtdigger.org.